Monday, March 07, 2005

Why women's attitude must be of emancipation and not empowerment.

Having recieved a substantial backlash from some brothers for my views on conformist African men, I thought that it is only fair that I attempt to level the playing field. Nevertheless, this article should not be taken as a digress from my previous position.

While it is imperative to reproach conformist African men for their iniquitous actions on women, ascribing sole blame on African men for the tribulations of African women is not completely fair. The quandary on who holds the ultimate responsibility lies not on the tyrants of gender injustice but on the erudite recipients of said injustice.

It is commonly said, especially in my field of criminal justice, "don't blame the victims". However, a victim is one who is powerless over her oppresors and in this particular case erudite recipients of injustice cannot really be termed as victims. As a matter of fact, African women and all women in general should be cautious on taking on a victim mentality. Accurately speaking, a victim mentality characteristically evolves to a pusillanimous mentality, which in turn empowers the oppressor instead of the "victim". This brings us to the debate on whether women empowerment is detrimental to the progress of women and whether we should actually use the term empowerment as opposed to emancipation. There is a formula to my madness.

Empower is synonymous to approve, authorize, allow or sanction while emancipation is synonymous to liberation, set free, deliver or unshackle. Subsequently when women seek empowerment they in retrospect ask men for permission to be free of injustice and gender discrimination. This in turn bolsters the tyrannical and imperceptive attitudes of conformist African men instead of working in favor of the women seeking gender equality. Ascetically speaking, emancipation demands rather than request relief. Women should never have to ask for what justly belongs to them.

In conclusion, this writer, implores progressive women to focus on emancipation rather than empowerment in curing the ills that plague oppressed women all over the world. A special note to women in muslim societies who suffer untold misery. An emancipation outlook sets the stage for battle against gender injustice and the violence against women. Bureaucratic figures need to be held responsible for non-enforcement of civil rights and women should use the tools they already possess to fight bigotry. Remember, there is no greater resource than human resource.

9 Comments:

Anonymous Anonymous said...

just to play devil's advocate here, i could argue that, emancipation of women and not their empowerment is detrimental to their development.
empowerment is from within - it cannot be given in any form externally but must instead come from within. implicitly, it cannot be taken away also. (after spending a solid 2 wks analysing the balance of gender and credit in microfinancing in rural bangladesh:) empowerment speaks directly to a turnabout in individual value for women, not just by the women themselves but by the the menfolk they have to live with. emancipation of women therefore does not do much for the individual since the mindset is still in some form of bondage...which is where all the change should begin.

enjoy reading your blog, keep it going.

4:48 PM  
Blogger karoki said...

in reply to "anonymous" I appreciate the critism, interesting way of contrasting emancipation with empowerment.

2:34 AM  
Blogger moggaless said...

I don't no whether I should support you or not; since If I do and someone seems it I might end up being sued just like you. This to me is "Protecting my conservative goodies in the valley of loopholes".

If you need a lawyer tell me....

8:49 AM  
Blogger Spidey/Tato said...

i actually agree with you 100% and in addition must add that this was very well written.

What i'd like to here is a woman's thought on this article...cant wait to hear mshairi or mama junkyard's comment.

9:42 AM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

Karoki,

It has been a while since I have been here and wow! What great writing! What amazing views.

Please come back and to the blogspehere. We need you. Hata kama we disagre I love the way you write and express your views.

OK...in relation to what you said:
I agree with the Black Looks re the context of word Empowerment.

As a feminist when I speak of being empowered I do not speak of having being given permission by a man or even by a fellow sister. What I mean is that I have been strengthened, be it through interaction with other men and women, or by God or whomever. It means that I have come to the realisation that I am able, capable, worthy. It means that I am free.

9:26 PM  
Anonymous Anonymous said...

you might seriously think about getting your stuff published...you could take over oyunga pala's spot on the saturday magazine...we need more writers like you, not afraid to say what they think ..and not afraid to take constructive criticism.....i loooove reading your blog...want to be my boyfriend? lol

3:43 PM  
Blogger karoki said...

Thank you for all your comments, encouragement and critism. I really do appreaciate them. feel free to drop a line at worshipsax@hotmail.com
Remember Our doubts are traitors, and make us lose the good we oft might win, by fearing to attempt"
M for M, Act i, Sc.5-shakespeare

3:48 AM  
Blogger Orkoiyot said...

lol! Why do i think that the email address was dropped at the opportune moment i.e. just after the kaproposal. lol!

I agree with the ladies though. The emancipation must to bounce chap chap from the minds of the womenfolk seeking empowerment. And having reached the level of empowerment, the need to behave empowered. The privileges to the 'victim lady' such as nominated mp opportunities and other free gifts to the female gender i think is detrimental and keeps them forever seeking emancipation and not empowerment.

5:00 AM  
Blogger AfroFeminista said...

Empowered - a state of being, where I feel that my survival and well being is in my control. I can take control.

Emancipated - a state where I am freed from the patriarchal shackles that seek to control me and move on to feeling in control i.e. empowered. Free!

12:28 AM  

Post a Comment

<< Home